Delivery and readiness for operation may be different stages.
Equipment may have arrived without being installed, tested or provided with the necessary operating conditions. Assessing payment and liability requires identifying each party’s stages and the connections the contract makes between them.
We examine supply, completeness, quality, repair and maintenance claims. Particular attention goes to identification, condition, operating history and preservation of the material needed for technical assessment of a failure’s causes.
Where equipment disputes arise
The supply differs from the specification
Disagreements concern the model, configuration, characteristics, documents or an alternative product. We compare the agreed specification version, correspondence and actual units delivered.
Payment is withheld until commissioning or testing
The parties dispute readiness, installation and acceptance conditions. We examine responsibility for the site, connections, staff and other prerequisites for the relevant stage.
A failure appears during the warranty period
Possible causes include manufacture, transport, storage, installation or operation. We examine how the defect was recorded, notices, inspections and the equipment’s full history.
The scope and price of completed repairs are disputed
Questions arise about diagnosis, replacement parts, approval of additional operations and test results. We distinguish commissioned repairs, new work and claims following another failure.
From a particular unit to responsibility under the contract
The legal position needs to connect the contract and defect with identifiable equipment, a particular stage and its period of use.
- Identification and completeness
- We check the description, model, serial numbers, accessories, specification versions and technical documents. We establish exactly what was delivered and who accepted it.
- Performance stages
- We distinguish delivery, installation, adjustment, testing and service. For each stage, we examine completion conditions, responsibilities, records and payment entitlement.
- The defect and its causes
- We compare initial condition, operating conditions, maintenance and the circumstances of failure. Describing a malfunction is distinct from establishing its cause and responsibility.
- Remediation and expenses
- We examine notice to the counterparty, opportunities to inspect and repair, preservation of replaced parts, third-party repairs and cost records. Claims are assessed against established circumstances.
How we examine supply and service contracts
- 01
Define the dispute
We identify equipment, contracts, stages and claims. Payment, completeness, defects, timing and additional expenditure are distinguished.
- 02
Reconstruct the history
We collect records from dispatch to current condition: delivery, storage, installation, commissioning, operation, requests and repairs.
- 03
Assess the evidence
We check whether equipment, parts and records remain available for inspection. Where needed, we agree technical questions for a specialist or expert.
- 04
Prepare the response
We formulate claims or objections, negotiation terms and a litigation position. For continuing service, we help clarify orders, acceptance and accounts.
Supplier and purchaser concerns
For suppliers and service providers
Substantiate performance, agreed configuration and additional work. Assess retention, warranty demands and third-party repair expenses in light of equipment operating conditions.
For purchasers and equipment owners
Record the non-conformity and required remedy, and assess claims against the supplier or contractor. Connect downtime, repairs and other expenses with the causes of failure and the contract terms.
Which documents help us assess the matter
- Supply and service scope
- Contracts, specifications, serial numbers, technical requirements, warranties and approved changes.
- Handover and commissioning
- Dispatch and delivery records, acceptance, installation, adjustment, testing and document-handover records.
- Use and defects
- Operating logs, maintenance records, photographs, inspection reports, notices and specialist findings.
- Repair and accounts
- Orders, diagnostics, estimates, replacement approvals, repair records, payments and evidence of disputed costs.
For the first enquiry, a brief description of the parties, amount, stage and urgent dates is enough. Detailed documents are shared after a conflict check and agreement on how we will work. An NDA can be agreed on request.
What the engagement can include
- Stages and responsibilities distinguished through a chronology of supply, operation, failure and repair.
- Assessment of quality and completeness evidence, payment entitlement and claimed expenses.
- Documents for negotiations, pre-action work or litigation, and questions for any necessary technical investigation.
