Нефтяной юристНефтегазовая практика Немкова Николая& ЮК "Консультант"Discuss a dispute
Oil & Gas practice · Across Russia

Geology, surveys & engineering design

Support on geological, survey and design contracts. We examine the agreed scope, delivery of results, changes, comments and payment conditions.

Surveys · Design documentation

First, establish which result was commissioned.

Disagreements often begin with different expectations: the contractor considers a stage complete, while the client expects a new revision or approval. Assessment requires the original assignment, input data, deliverables and review procedure.

We address the contractual side of the project: payment for investigations and documentation, scope changes, comments and liability. Technical findings are examined with appropriate specialists where resolving a question requires specialist knowledge.

When a legal issue arises

01

Input data arrives late or changes

The programme remains unchanged while the assignment and supporting information evolve. We examine responsibility for the data, its required contents, requests and the impact on particular stages.

02

Comments become a new assignment

The contractor receives additional requirements described as corrections. We compare them with the original scope, approval history and grounds for adjusting price and time.

03

A delivered stage remains unpaid

Payment is linked to approval, expert review or the start of the next stage. We examine the exact terms, delivery and comments on the relevant document version.

04

The project stops or changes contractor

Incomplete stages, advances, prepared materials and their further use remain unresolved. We distinguish the work performed, results delivered and each party’s demands.

The basis of the position

Tracing the assignment through to delivery

Document versions and the decisions taken on them matter. A final folder without its revision history may not explain how the scope developed.

Input data
We examine required information, responsibility for supplying it and access to current versions. Assumptions agreed before missing data arrived are identified separately.
Stage boundaries
What is a standalone deliverable, and what are its acceptance criteria? We examine document contents, delivery format, programme and the relationship between stages and payment.
Comment history
We distinguish defect correction, clarification and a changed assignment. Comments are linked to the relevant version, contractor responses and authorised decisions.
Delivery and use
We review issue registers, letters, file access, acceptance records and terms of use. The scope delivered is assessed separately from the decision to stop the project.

How we assess a design dispute

  1. 01

    Establish the original scope

    We review the contract, assignment, stages and input data. We identify whether the disagreement concerns scope, quality, timing or payment entitlement.

  2. 02

    Build the revision history

    We trace delivery of data, outputs, comments and corrections. Decisions affecting price and programme are identified.

  3. 03

    Examine the claims

    We compare work performed, advances, payments, additional expenditure and penalties. For technical disputes, we define the subject of specialist investigation.

  4. 04

    Formulate the position

    We prepare documents for negotiations, pre-action work or litigation. If the project continues, we help agree the remaining scope and acceptance arrangements.

The interests of each party

For survey and design businesses

Substantiate delivery and the effect of new data on the scope. Distinguish correction of defects from additional requirements, and support accounts for completed or discontinued stages.

For clients commissioning the work

Check completeness, conformity with the assignment and the substance of comments. Assess corrections, responsibility for defects and claims without combining different document revisions.

Which documents help us assess the matter

Assignment and terms
The contract, technical assignment, programme, stage descriptions, deliverable requirements and payment procedure.
Input data
Delivery registers, requests for missing information, replies and revised data with dates received.
Results and versions
File inventories, delivery letters, acceptance records, document sets, comments and responses.
Approvals and accounts
Decision records, expert-review materials where applicable, stage calculations, advances, payments and termination notices.

For the first enquiry, a brief description of the parties, amount, stage and urgent dates is enough. Detailed documents are shared after a conflict check and agreement on how we will work. An NDA can be agreed on request.

Commercial terms

Terms for the court stage

from ₽1 million

First instance and appeal of one dispute, combined

We handle commercial disputes from ₽20 million. The specific scope, payment schedule and expenses are recorded in the engagement contract.

Paid initial consultation
The scope of the review and its price are agreed before the consultation. Start with a short description of the matter.
Separate stages and expenses
Cassation, enforcement, insolvency proceedings, experts, court fees and travel are agreed separately.
Ongoing support
Contract reviews, pre-action work and recurring support can be agreed as a separate engagement.
Questions

Before we begin

What should be examined first when input data is missing and time is running out?

The obligation to supply it, the missing items, requests sent and their effect on particular work. We establish which stages could proceed and what decisions the parties made about the programme.

Are comments after stage approval always additional work?

No. Their substance matters. A comment may concern a defect, new input data or a changed assignment. Assessment requires the accepted version, correspondence and contractual correction rules.

How is completed work assessed when a project is cancelled?

We compare stages, actual progress, materials delivered, advances and termination terms. Further use of the result and the parties’ claims are considered separately. A standard payment percentage would not address those differences.

What if payment depends on a favourable expert-review conclusion?

We examine the wording, responsibility for the review process and why the conclusion is absent. The relevant stage and the actions within each party’s control need to be established.

Does an adverse review automatically establish the designer’s fault?

The substance of the conclusion needs assessment. We compare comments with the assignment, input data, relevant revision and contractor’s obligations. Causation and technical justification may require specialist input.

Contact

Start with
your situation.

Tell us what happened under the contract, the amount at issue and the current stage. We will confirm whether we can act and explain the paid consultation process.

Confidential. Documents are shared after we check whether we can act. NDA available on request.
Mon–Fri · 10:00–19:00
Contact details and your matter
You are contacting us
Company and counterpartyOptional
Name and phone are required.