Нефтяной юристНефтегазовая практика Немкова Николая& ЮК "Консультант"Discuss a dispute
Oil & Gas practice · Across Russia

Industrial construction & pipelines

Contractual and court matters for clients, main contractors and subcontractors on industrial and pipeline projects. Acceptance, additional work, quality, timing and final accounts.

Industrial projects · Construction contracts

Completed quantities and an agreed price are separate questions.

Design decisions, programmes and the mix of contractors may all change on a construction site. Evidence that work was performed needs to be assessed against the agreed scope, approved changes, as-built records and payment terms.

We examine each level of the contracting chain. A subcontractor’s claim against a main contractor and the client’s demands may concern the same site while involving different grounds, evidence and calculations.

Key construction disputes

01

Work is offered for acceptance but not accepted

Quantities, completion documents or grounds for rejection are disputed. We examine the handover procedure, delivery of documents, specific comments and actual use of the result.

02

Additional work remains unpaid

A change originated on site or in a revised design. We examine who initiated it, how necessity and price were approved and which notices were sent.

03

Penalties and damages are claimed

Delay is attributed to the contractor, site handover, supplies or other participants. We reconstruct obstacles and their effect on particular stages.

04

The contract ends before accounts are settled

Completed work, advances, materials, equipment, defects and completion costs need to be distinguished. We examine the condition of the project at termination and the parties’ subsequent actions.

The basis of the position

Four foundations of a construction position

The contract, design, actual performance and financial calculation need to explain the same sequence of events.

Scope and changes
We compare the assignment, estimate and design revisions. We distinguish the original scope from changes, clarifications and repeated work, and establish the approval procedure.
Handover and records
We examine acceptance certificates, KS-2 and KS-3 forms where used under the contract, as-built drawings, concealed-work records and tests. For pipeline projects, we also compare weld and inspection records with project requirements.
Time and dependencies
We compare the programme with access, documentation, materials and related work. We examine notices of obstacles and decisions about adjusting deadlines.
Defects and expenditure
We distinguish documentation comments from defects in the result. We assess inspections, causes, opportunities to remedy and evidence of the claimed rectification costs.

How we work through the project

  1. 01

    Define the disputed scope

    We separate claims by contract, stage, work type and design revision. We identify agreed amounts and the specific disagreements.

  2. 02

    Build the evidence

    We connect certificates and calculations with logs, correspondence, as-built records and evidence of handover.

  3. 03

    Assess technical questions

    We identify matters supported by documents and those requiring inspection or expert examination. We review the source material for that assessment.

  4. 04

    Prepare claims or a defence

    We formulate the position on payment, penalties, defects and counterclaims. Settlement terms are considered in light of project completion.

The company’s place in the contracting chain

For clients and main contractors

We examine quantities claimed, the basis for additional charges, quality and documentation. We help formulate comments and demands tied to specific obligations and project circumstances.

For contractors and subcontractors

We examine evidence of completed work, approval of changes, retention and delay objections. We separately assess how the client and other contractors affected performance of the company’s own contract.

Which documents help us assess the matter

Contract and design
Construction contracts, assignments, estimates, programmes, design and working documents with revision histories.
Site performance
Logs, as-built drawings, concealed-work and test records, weld inspection documents, site handover and material transfer records.
Acceptance and comments
Acceptance certificates, applicable KS-2 and KS-3 forms, evidence of delivery, defect schedules and responses.
Accounts and completion
Advances, payments, retention, additional-work calculations, termination notices and inventories of transferred property.

For the first enquiry, a brief description of the parties, amount, stage and urgent dates is enough. Detailed documents are shared after a conflict check and agreement on how we will work. An NDA can be agreed on request.

Commercial terms

Terms for the court stage

from ₽1 million

First instance and appeal of one dispute, combined

We handle commercial disputes from ₽20 million. The specific scope, payment schedule and expenses are recorded in the engagement contract.

Paid initial consultation
The scope of the review and its price are agreed before the consultation. Start with a short description of the matter.
Separate stages and expenses
Cassation, enforcement, insolvency proceedings, experts, court fees and travel are agreed separately.
Ongoing support
Contract reviews, pre-action work and recurring support can be agreed as a separate engagement.
Questions

Before we begin

Is it worth reviewing additional work without a signed amendment?

Yes, but performance alone does not decide payment entitlement. We examine the need for the work, instructions, notices, approval of scope and price, and the particular contract terms.

Does a unilaterally signed acceptance certificate establish the debt?

Its significance depends on handover circumstances and the other party’s objections. We examine the procedure, delivery, reasons for rejection, actual result and other evidence. One document should not determine the conclusion in isolation.

Does missing as-built documentation mean payment is lost?

We need to identify required records, what was provided and the purpose of the missing material. We then assess payment terms and the connection between the comments and the work delivered.

How can we assess another contractor’s defect-remediation bill?

We examine how defects were recorded, invitations to inspect, notices and the original contractor’s opportunity to remedy them. We compare the repairs, causes and supported costs, seeking expert input where needed.

Can issues across the whole site be assessed together?

Yes, for understanding the events. Claims and liability still need to be distinguished by contract and participant. A shared site does not replace analysis of each party’s particular obligation.

Contact

Start with
your situation.

Tell us what happened under the contract, the amount at issue and the current stage. We will confirm whether we can act and explain the paid consultation process.

Confidential. Documents are shared after we check whether we can act. NDA available on request.
Mon–Fri · 10:00–19:00
Contact details and your matter
You are contacting us
Company and counterpartyOptional
Name and phone are required.